What is so intriguing about tragic endings, tragic characters, and plays? Many of Shakespeare's most notable works were tragedies; Romeo and Juliet, Macbeth, Othello, Anthony and Cleopatra and of course, King Lear. I tend to believe people like seeing chaos and tragedy on stage because it mirrors most people's day to day reality so it is easily relatable. As depressing as this may sound, I truly think tragedy is just another word for reality, especially in Shakespeare. Obviously the writing and plots are more exaggerated, but everyone, the world over, can relate to death, relationships and family problems, and the conflict that each can bring.
During our four years of English studies, we have learned that for one of Shakespeare's plays to be considered "tragic" it must follow this outline. First, the protagonist must be noble with likeable qualities but a tragic flaw. Second, there must be tragic order, some chaotic experience, defying laws of nature and morality. Third, a general conflict, fourth, a character seeking revenge or avenging themselves, family, etc. Fifth, comic relief to keep some scenes light-hearted and secure a pleasant undertone for the play. Sixth, the main character has to experience a period of isolation and finally, the play must end in death, downfall or destruction.
In my mind, every element listed is paralleled in real life. Everyone has good and bad qualities, we are generally likeable but all have flaws and problems we must face. We all seek revenge on occasion and either do things or contemplate doing things that can be considered unethical. As humans we sometimes feel isolated or we distance ourselves voluntarily. We all have moments of happiness where we are uplifted by someone or something. Everyone experiences good times and bad, and eventually our lives all come to an end. So my question to all of you is this, is tragedy merely another word for the reality we all live day to day? Are the lives we are living tragic?
Taylor, you hit on some really good points. I really like how you broke down what a tragedy is - as for your thought provoking question, the romantic in me disagrees. I think that while our lives are filled with tragedy, losing loved ones or the drama that is in life, I find life is a rewarding experience.
ReplyDeleteBut I think one's personal life can seem a bit tragic. Mine mirror's more of a comedic (Twelfth Night, Much Ado) kind of life. But certainly there are people who have lives that are more akin to Othello or Macbeth.
The most relatable tragedy is probably King Lear; though we're not there yet, I think many people who have regrets in their lives probably die in the despair that Lear has. Certainly an interesting thought Taylor.